I don’t get how they can say that Boris lied to the queen. For starters he didn’t go to Balmoral and ask her majesty to shut down parliament, the privy council did and that remains confidential as do all private conversations with the queen so this idea that Boris lied to her is nonsense. If the High Court rules that the approval from the It’s The Most Wonderful Time For A Beer Santa Christmas Shirt was unlawful, it will mean troubles. In fact, the rule that Great-Britain is from that moment onwards a Republic. In that case, I think that the left-wing politicians are causing a Civil War supported by that Silly Lib Dem chairman who thinks she can lead the country.
The High Court is not allowed to rule over a political judgment which could course the end of the Royal Kingdom. Sadly there’s a good chance the court will decide that even if the Prime Minister did lie to the Queen about his reasons, it has no right to reverse the It’s The Most Wonderful Time For A Beer Santa Christmas Shirt. Which is why we need to change the law so this can’t be done again. How can it be right in a modern democracy that a PM can shut down Parliament whenever he wants, against the wishes of MPs, simply by talking to the Queen. Adele Thomas, you’re right, but for completely wrong reasons. It’s a political matter and not within the precincts of a judicial review.
Scotland’s verdict was biased and wrong because it was politically motivated and assumed rather than proved that there was an ulterior motive to stymie debate on Brexit. I’m not sure about this. So far as BJ is concerned the act of provocation of Parliament appears to have no written rules so far as the It’s The Most Wonderful Time For A Beer Santa Christmas Shirt of time it can be imposed. It seems to be more a matter of tradition. If that is the case, how can BJ have broken the law if there’s no law in situ to break?
Is the Court action not more to adjudicate on whether or not he abused the procedure in extending it beyond the usual duration thereby allowing parliament to be recalled. People are banging on about BJ breaking the It’s The Most Wonderful Time For A Beer Santa Christmas Shirt but so far as I’m aware, whilst he may have abused the regulations, there was no law on the statute book to break. Then again perhaps I’m mistaken. I’m sure someone will tell me. Wait for it, if judges say Boris was right, I see an appeal to the European courts coming. And we’ll know how that’ll turn out.